“...all decisions were objective until the first line of code was written. After that, all decisions were emotional.” Ben Horowitz in "The Hard Thing About Hard Things"

A concept I've referred to in the past (Being Human #35, Techniques for FIT #130, blog Sunk Costs) is management using minimum acceptable standards. This came up in a call when a CEO mentioned in an off-hand way "and if you can help with that sick to your stomach feeling when you have to fire someone, that'd be great." The funny thing about his comment is I've been there. I've been part of some fast-growing businesses where people came and went before I even knew if they had pets. Minimum acceptable standards came from those experiences.
With every action you take there is a desired outcome you're hoping for. Whether it's hiring a vendor, hiring an employee, making an investment, buying a company, whatever. We're pretty good at describing best case scenario good outcomes. Stronger branding, higher quality work, financial returns, an expanded market, etc. We may even do a little "worst case scenario" outcome visioning. There's nothing wrong with these exercises, but as Ben H. states up top, our objectivity goes out the window once we start doing the work.
Start early
Committing to minimum acceptable standards long before the work begins can help us stay objective. For instance, if we know that a new hire's first week is the most critical week of their first year we can make plans to make the week amazing. We can also imagine some instances where the first week goes off the rails just a bit. In addition to those planning for success I suggest you take some time and work through, objectively, what the absolute minimum standards for the first week are. Before your manager ever brings this person in, what is the worst first week you'd accept from your team?
This exercise helps you avoid future stomach churn because you can communicate all expectations your management/training team up front. Saying, "I expect this, will be happy with that, and if any of these bad things happen we need to visit," up front is powerful. However, when I describe this to clients, they tend to look at me like "hmm. . .no way that works."
The secret
Here's the secret. You can't set minimum acceptable standards above what currently happens in your team without consequences. If you say there will be consequences if a new hire goes through an hour waiting for an activity, yet the last two hires think, "Hour? I had to keep myself busy most of the first month!" it won't be a minimum standard. This is where culture eats strategy, as they say.
Minimums work, but you have to know what your unwritten minimums are before attempting to put new ones in place. It takes time and effort, but in the end, no upset stomachs for all sides. You know what's expected, your people know what's expected and you both charge forward confidently.
It works. Good stuff.
The Business Development seminar I'm hosting in Sept. touches on minimum acceptable standards as it applies to opportunity development. If you're curious, learn more here.
|